The NHS has never measured more. We count waits, contacts, admissions, bed days, referrals and discharges, and report them weekly, monthly and quarterly to boards, ICBs, regions and national teams. Yet people in England now spend almost a quarter of their lives in poor health, and healthy life expectancy has gone backwards. Public satisfaction with the NHS, which stood at 70% in 2010, fell to a record low of 21% in 2024 and has only just started to recover. Nearly one in three staff say they’re burnt out, and fewer would recommend the NHS as a place to work than a year ago.

When patients feel worse about the care they get, staff feel worse about the care they give and people’s health is heading the wrong way, all while the dashboards keep multiplying, it’s hard not to ask the obvious question. Are we measuring the right things?

That question is especially pressing for neighbourhood health, which is now being asked to fix many of these problems. But how do we avoid falling into the same measurement mistakes that has created a fragmented unresponsive impersonal system that neighbourhood health is being developed to fix. This article looks at why more measurement hasn’t made us healthier, how targets so often push problems out of sight rather than solving them, and six practical ways neighbourhood teams, commissioners and partners can measure differently.

Something Went Wrong, So Now We Measure It Forever

In the NHS, measurement has become the answer to almost every problem. Something goes wrong, and a new measure appears to make sure it never happens again. Often the problem doesn’t even need to happen. It only takes someone important to be concerned that it ‘might’. Meanwhile, our computer systems are driving us to measure everything, everywhere, all at once, all the time.

The trouble is that measures are very easy to start and politically difficult to stop. They pile up like sediment, each layer laid down on the one before and providing the foundation for the next, and each one still waiting to be collected, checked, chased and reported long after anyone remembers the crisis that created it.

Measurement Piles up around a nurse in the swamping them in generations of paperwork.

I’ve spent countless hours of my working life writing reports explaining what those numbers meant. Hours I could have spent out with the team, fixing the problems behind the numbers or making the service better for the people using it. This is becoming an ever bigger problem for clinicians too. With managers and admin staff first in line to be cut, the work simply gets pushed onto clinicians instead, so more of their time goes on feeding the ever-hungry data monster and less on patients.

Much of this is about reassuring our anxious systems. A measure feels like control. It tells the board, the regulator and the minister that someone is keeping an eye on things, and when there’s a problem or a concern, being able to say “we’re measuring it” feels comforting. But feeling reassured and getting better are two very different things, and every measure is a tax on people’s time and attention that comes straight out of time with patients and communities.

How Do NHS Targets Push Problems Out of Sight?

Measuring a problem can shine a light on it. But when there’s no clear or obvious solution, our healthcare system has a tendency to push problems from the places we can see to the places we can’t. We see this when services improve for some while health inequalities deepen for those who cannot or do not access services. We see it in the ‘missing middle’ of mental health, where people fall between the thresholds for different levels of support. And we see it in rising failure demand, as unmet needs resurface elsewhere in the system, often more complex and more expensive to address. The numbers may improve, but the underlying problems haven’t necessarily gone away. They’ve simply moved beyond the reach of our measurements.

The Information Bubble

Managers making a decision look at data and often sit in an information bubble protected from the reality of healthcare

That reality is often hidden from the people who actually make the decisions in healthcare. Every NHS decision maker works inside an information bubble, built from the papers, dashboards and meetings that reach them, and from the inside it looks remarkably like the whole picture. Most of us never realise we’re in one. And once we put a measure on a problem, the quickest way to improve the number is often to push the problem out of the bubble.

There’s a lovely story about this from the history of mapmaking. (as explained by Hannah Fry in the short video below) In 1798 the geographer James Rennell drew a great mountain range across West Africa, based on a distant glimpse reported by the explorer Mungo Park and Rennell’s own theory about the course of the River Niger. Other mapmakers copied it, then copied each other, and for most of the next century the Mountains of Kong appeared on nearly every major map of Africa. What’s interesting is that over decades generations of map makers and explorers kept adding their own details until the mountain range stretched across the entire of Africa! It wasn’t until the French explorer Louis-Gustave Binger actually went to look in the late 1880s that anyone discovered they weren’t there.

Plenty of NHS dashboards have their own Mountains of Kong: an assumption, a definition or a baseline that started life as somebody’s best guess, then got copied from paper to paper until nobody remembers it was ever a guess at all. From inside the bubble, they look as solid as anything else on the map. When we start with a problem, especially when defined by a powerful decision maker or even NHS England people are rewarded for building up the problems and the solutions, given more and more detail until every intervention if extended far enough will inevitably significantly reduce demand on services.

An Example: Assessment Targets

Take assessments. Set a target for how quickly people are assessed, and services get very good at assessing people quickly, what Gwyn Bevan and Christopher Hood famously called “hitting the target and missing the point”. In NHS Talking Therapies, for instance, services routinely hit the national target to see over 75% of referrals within six weeks, because the clock stops at the initial assessment. Yet Royal College of Psychiatrists data exposed a massive “hidden waiting list” behind that green dashboard, with tens of thousands of people waiting over three months between their assessment and their second appointment for actual therapy.

What the target can’t see is that wait after the assessment, the person turned away because they didn’t quite meet the threshold, or the referral bounced to another service with its own queue. The number goes green, while the problem simply moves outside the bubble onto the person who needed help and whoever picks them up next.

Nobody does this out of malice. People under enormous pressure, doing exactly what the system asks of them, will always find the quickest way to make the number move. Those who don’t are blamed, and those who do are praised and rewarded. That’s the system working exactly as it was designed, and it’s why, as the economist Charles Goodhart and the anthropologist Marilyn Strathern observed, when a measure becomes a target it ceases to be a good measure.

Why Neighbourhood Health Risks Dissolving into Bubbles

Neighbourhood Health Services becoing their own little bubbles of care leaving people on the outside

Neighbourhood health has a version of this risk all of its own. As the work spreads across GP practices, neighbourhood providers, community services, councils, charities and acute trusts, each organisation quite naturally builds its own bubble, with its own data, its own dashboards and its own reports to its own board. Push a problem out of one bubble and it pops into someone else’s, or worse, it falls into the gaps between them.

People’s lives don’t respect any of those boundaries. A family might be known to the health visitor, the school, the housing team and the foodbank, each holding a piece of the picture and nobody holding all of it. Neighbourhood health was supposed to join things up, yet without real care it could dissolve into a froth of little bubbles, each one perfectly clear on the inside and blind to everything around it.

As each service comes under pressure to justify its funding in a system that is making cuts to make ends meet, the pressure to meet contractual commitments and service goals, and to justify its existence, risks driving services apart. In a system where organisations are being made to compete, you don’t get more collaboration or holistic care. You get ever tighter bubbles of decision making that focus only on what those at the top are focused on, and not on what people care about and need. Indeed, that seems to be precisely the mechanism that has left us with a fragmented system. All too often, measurement has been contributing to the problem rather than enabling the solution.

What Is Measurement Actually For?

A healthcare meeting where clinicians and managers discuss the emotions around an intervention

I think the obsession with measurement too often missing the point: The purpose of measurement is to help us make better decisions, so that we know the right thing to do next. Hitting the target, proving we did what we promised and feeding the quarterly return are by products at best. If we always do whatever the numbers tell us, that’s a process rather than a decision.

This is where the bubble really can really squeeze us in. Fix the measures too tightly and the bubble narrows, until we can only see the things we’ve already decided to look for, and every decision gets made from a smaller and smaller picture of the world. Worse, we start trying to fit the world into our bubble, reshaping services, pathways and even people’s lives so that they show up neatly in the numbers. Measurement that doesn’t improve our decisions leaves us less able to understand what’s really happening, and less able to make any difference to it. And surely making a difference to people’s lives is the whole point.

Mearurement is inform-ation. Used to inform our decsions.

What Does the Neighbourhood Health Framework Leave to Local Teams?

To be fair, the Neighbourhood Health Framework has set fairly broad headline targets: fewer emergency admissions and bed days for people living with frailty and at the end of life, better outcomes for long-term conditions, same-day access for urgent GP appointments, and care plans for people with complex needs. You can argue about them, and plenty of us will, but at least they’re clear. I’m sure the intention is for services to collaborate to achieve them.

What it hasn’t set are the measures people use to run a neighbourhood day to day: the ones that decide where the team goes this week, who they call first and which partner they work with, how they decide which person gets their time and attention, and what they do with them.

Different levels of the system make different decisions on very different rhythms. National targets move over years, an ICB decides where the money goes over months, and a neighbourhood team decides what to do on Monday morning. One set of numbers can’t serve all of them, and when we try, it usually ends up serving the top.

That gap is a real opportunity. Left alone, it will fill up by default with the same activity counts, contact numbers and assessment times we’ve always used, and neighbourhood health will inherit all the problems of the existing system and risk failing in exactly the same way. Or we can use measurement to make things better.

The metrics for neighbourhood health are at multiple different levels and speeds

How Can Neighbourhood Health Measure Differently?

So what could we learn from decades of measuring the NHS? Here are six lessons I’d put in front of any neighbourhood team, commissioner or partnership before they agree a single measure.

1. Start With the Situation, Not the Spreadsheet

Before anyone opens a spreadsheet, get a shared picture of what’s actually going on in the neighbourhood, why it’s happening and what’s coming next. Who lives here, what are they dealing with, and what are services and partners seeing? Then name the handful of decisions the team really has to make in the next few months, and ask what would change your mind about each of them. The measures worth having are the ones that would change a decision. My guide to how to measure neighbourhood health walks through this in more detail.

2. Match Each Measure to a Decision and a Rhythm

For every measure, be able to say who uses it, for which decision and how often. National and ICB measures can move quarterly or yearly, but a neighbourhood team deciding where to focus next week needs information that moves weekly, and a practitioner sitting with a family needs that person’s own priorities in their own words. If a measure doesn’t line up with a real decision on the right rhythm, it’s probably serving the top rather than the work.

3. Give Every Measure a Sell-By Date

Keep a simple register of what you measure: who owns each measure, which decision it informs, when it was introduced, why, and when it will next be reviewed. If a measure was brought in after a crisis or a concern, agree up front when it will be reviewed and retired. And if a measure hasn’t changed a single decision in the past year, it should have to make a very good case for staying. Make every measure earn its keep.

4. Follow the Problem When the Number Improves

When a number goes green, ask where the problem went. Look at the step after the one you’re measuring, such as the wait after the assessment. Check the referrals that were rejected or redirected, the people who didn’t come back, and the demand turning up somewhere else, whether that’s 111, urgent care or a charity’s front door. Ask the frontline and your community partners what they’re seeing. If the problem has simply moved to another service or back onto the person, nothing has really got better.

5. Let the Outside In

Ask who isn’t in the room and what they can see that you can’t. The foodbank, the school, the housing officer and people with lived experience often spot trouble months before it shows up in a GP appointment or an admission. Bring them into regular sense-making, not just one-off engagement, and keep their stories and comments alongside the numbers, because that’s often where the real learning is.

6. Join the Little Bubbles Up

Agree a small number of shared signals across all the organisations working in the neighbourhood, so that what each partner sees can finally be put together. Hold regular joint reviews where the practice, community services, the council and voluntary sector partners look at those signals together and decide what to do. Resist the temptation for every organisation to build its own dashboard, because that’s exactly how the froth of little bubbles forms.

Seeing It Coming

We’ll never stop people measuring, ranking and judging. But the people closest to the work see things no dashboard ever will, and they can learn and adapt far faster than any system can judge them. Neighbourhood health has a rare chance to build its measures around what they see, rather than around what makes the rest of the system feel safe. It would be a terrible shame to waste it on another dashboard.

Data bringing communities together communities together to make better decisions and make sense of their lives

Conclusion

None of this is an argument against measurement. Numbers are one of the most powerful tools we have, and neighbourhood health will need good ones to learn, to make its case and to show where the money is making a difference. The real question is whether we use them to see more of the world, or to shrink the world down until it fits our dashboards.

The NHS has spent decades building measures that tell the centre what it wants to know, and we’ve ended up with green screens, full waiting rooms and a population that isn’t getting any healthier. Neighbourhood health doesn’t have to repeat that. It’s being built at the edge, close to where people actually live, and that gives it something the rest of the system rarely has: the chance to spot problems early, understand why they’re happening and act while there are still real choices to make.

That means starting with the situation rather than the spreadsheet, tying every measure to a real decision, following problems when the numbers improve, and joining up what every partner in a neighbourhood can see. Get that right, and measurement can finally do what it was always meant to do: help us understand the reality people are living, and make a difference to it.

We’ll never stop people measuring, ranking and judging. But the people closest to the work see things no dashboard ever will, and they can learn and adapt far faster than any system can judge them. Neighbourhood health has a rare chance to build its measures around what they see, rather than around what makes the rest of the system feel safe. It would be a terrible shame to waste it on another dashboard.

Next Steps

This article grew out of my part of a recent Neighbourhood Health Academy Live session, How Do We Measure Neighbourhood Health? Join the Neighbourhood Health Academy to watch the full recording, including presentations from Dr Marie Polley MBE and John Mortimer. It’s free, and it’s a community of people working to make neighbourhood health work.

A scale with neighbourhood on one side and a lot of measurement reports on the other

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do NHS targets have unintended consequences?

Because people under pressure will always find the quickest way to move the number they’re judged on, and the quickest way is often to move the problem rather than solve it. A target on assessment times can create hidden waits after assessment, and tight eligibility criteria can leave people in the gaps between services. Once a measure becomes a target, it stops telling you much about what’s really happening.

What is an information bubble in healthcare?

It’s the picture of the world decision makers build from the papers, dashboards and meetings that reach them. From the inside it looks like the whole picture, but much of what shapes people’s health, such as housing, jobs, debt and loneliness, never makes it in. Decisions made inside the bubble can look sensible in the boardroom and make little sense in the neighbourhood.

What is failure demand in the NHS?

Failure demand is demand caused by a failure to do something, or to do it right, the first time. People come back because their problem wasn’t solved, or turn up somewhere else with needs that have become more complex and more expensive. The Health Foundation describes it as the hidden work holding back NHS productivity.

What targets does the Neighbourhood Health Framework set?

The framework sets headline goals including reductions in emergency admissions and bed days for people with frailty and at the end of life, better outcomes for long-term conditions such as diabetes and cardiovascular disease, same-day access for clinically urgent GP appointments, and agreed care plans for people with complex needs. It doesn’t set the day-to-day measures neighbourhood teams use to run their work.

How should neighbourhood teams choose their day-to-day measures?

Start with the situation and the decisions the team actually makes, then choose a small number of measures that would change those decisions. Match each one to the right rhythm, review them regularly, keep people’s own words alongside the numbers, and share a few signals across all the partners in the neighbourhood rather than building separate dashboards.

Further reading

If you’re working out what to measure for your own neighbourhood, service or partnership, get in touch.